1 Jul 2, 2009
| TOR 2 NYY 4 | Final |
| MIL 1 CHC 2 | Final/10 |
| PIT 7 FLA 2 | Top 8 |
| ATL 9 WSH 6 | Bot 8 |
| NYM 2 PHI 7 | Bot 8 |
| OAK 3 CLE 14 | Top 7 |
| SEA 5 BOS 5 | Top 10 |
| STL 4 CIN 4 | Bot 8 |
| TB 1 TEX 2 | Bot 5 |
| ARI 0 COL 1 | Bot 5 |
| CWS 4 KC 0 | Bot 6 |
| DET 7 MIN 2 | Bot 5 |
| BAL @ LAA | 10:05 PM |
| LAD @ SD | 10:05 PM |
| HOU @ SF | 10:15 PM |