1 Mar. 16, 2010
| ATL 4 vs. FLA 2 | Final |
| DET 6 vs. PIT 3 | Final |
| MIN 2 vs. TB 5 | Final |
| NYY 2 vs. PHI 6 | Final |
| NYM 4 vs. BOS 2 | Final |
| TOR 4 vs. BAL 1 | Final |
| WSH 2 vs. HOU 11 | Final |
| ARI 7 vs. LAA 6 | Final |
| CWS 5 vs. LAD 1 | Final |
| MIL 5 vs. CIN 2 | Final |
| SD 16 vs. KC 14 | Final |
| SF 6 vs. OAK 1 | Final |
| CLE 3 vs. COL 6 | Final |
| CLE 8 vs. CIN 2 | Final |
| TEX 8 vs. SEA 1 | Final |