1 Jul. 3, 2009
| ATL 3 vs. WSH 5 | Final |
| MIL 11 vs. CHC 2 | Final |
| SEA 3 vs. BOS 2 | Final |
| TOR 5 vs. NYY 6 | Final/12 |
| CWS 4 vs. KC 6 | Final |
| STL 2 vs. CIN 5 | Final |
| HOU 0 vs. SF 9 | Final |
| NYM 1 vs. PHI 4 | Final |
| DET 3 vs. MIN 4 | Final |
| LAD 4 vs. SD 7 | Final |
| PIT 3 vs. FLA 5 | Final |
| OAK 2 vs. CLE 5 | Final |
| TB 4 vs. TEX 12 | Final |
| ARI 11 vs. COL 7 | Final |
| BAL 4 vs. LAA 11 | Final |